Last week's surfwear episode was mostly meh for me. Mitchell was finally sent home because the judges realized he was incompetent and lazy, and the producers realized he was boring. You should've known, Mitchell: if you're going to be a waste of space, you have to be compelling about it. Hosea from
Top Chef knew this: he made his quest to be The Worst an epic journey full of twists and turns, complete with cheating on his girlfriend with Leah (aka The First Runner-Up of Worst), consistently butchering seafood all the while claiming to be a seafood chef (from Denver...), and getting into constant pissing matches with Stefan, who was so obviously superior to Hosea that it should have been laughable. And it
was laughable, until Stefan was done in by his hubris and Hosea was rewarded for his persistent, unprecedented badness by winning his season, something which still causes me to cringe every time I think about it. When he made and appearance on
Top Chef Masters last month, eating and critiquing the food of chefs who are light years beyond him in every respect, I nearly vomited. Every time they showed him making a comment, I said, very loudly, "shut up, Hosea, you're The Worst." I'm not even lying.
But good gracious do I digress: Surfwear. Um...ok. Whatever. I'm sure that, somewhere, Ari and Malvin are sitting there going "seriously?" Ari would have made a dress that looked like a surfboard, and Malvin's would have been made out of sand, leaving a trail in his model's wake. And those would have been their every-day looks; I can't even begin to try to think about imagining what their avant garde looks would have been like. My brain doesn't bend that way. Whatever either of them made would have been hideous and unwearable, natch, but at least they would have been INTERESTING, MY GOD this season has been so boring. The challenge felt really perfunctory (we're in California! Let's do something...beachy? With surfers? Sure why not!), and the word macrame was used a bajillion times and the only dress I really remember was Ra'mon's lime green neoprene concoction with the weird gray dye splotch that actually wasn't too hideous. Also, it was the only avant garde look that seemed to have anything to do with surfwear. And I have to like it, if only because it sealed Mitchell's doom. And Michael Kors was again MIA, and I still haven't figured out what Rachel Bilson added to the conversation (when Lindsay Lohan offers better, more thoughtful and constructive criticism than you do, yikes).
Moving on to last night's episode:
CAN WE PLEASE SHOP SOMEWHERE OTHER THAN MOOD? Don't get me wrong, I love the weekly trips to the fabric store, but that's just it, they haven't had to use anything other than fabric to make clothes. These people are getting off light, and yet they continue to whine and moan and break needles. I so want Austin Scarlett to flounce in as only he can flounce and contemptuously throw ears of corn at them all. It would be glorious.
Anyhoo: Oh, the model-as-client challenge. Yet again, several of the models display an astonishing lack of fashion sense and/or an inability to coherently convey what they want to wear. Several designers blather on about staying true to themselves/their instincts in defiance of their clients' lack of taste. Tim dispenses sage advice, and several people listen to him. Epperson talks to his family and cries and my heart melts, and I kinda love his dress, even though I wouldn't be caught dead in it. Logan takes his clothes off, because apparently that's his schtick. Michael Kors AND Nina Garcia are nowhere to be found, which I find very worrying.
Quick impressions as the dresses came down the runway:
-Qrystil's dress is nice and boring.
-Nicolas's dress is white.
-Irina's looks dowdy.
-LOVE Gordana's dress.
-Shirin's is boring and short.
-Logan's is a prom-ish nightmare.
-Christopher's is actually good.
-Epperson's looks really cool.
-Addict guy's dress is bad.
-Althea's is meh.
-Louise's is cool, i dig the neck.
-Ra'mon's has a giant flower.
-Carol Hannah's model looks old. Beautiful and classy, but old.
The scary lady guest judge told a model to her face that she has no fashion sense. It was awesome in a "wow, what a raging bitch" kind of way. Marc Bouwer is wearing more makeup than Heidi, but his hair is gorgeous. In the previews, Heidi said one of the dresses aged the model, and as soon as Carol Hannah's model turned the corner, I thought Heidi was talking about her. But no, she was referring to Qristyl's model, who I didn't think looked old, just boring as all hell. Shows what I know. Logan's dress is really, memorably ugly. Addict Guy seems to have reached a zen calm, so, good for him, make some better dresses now. The judges loved Epperson's dress, and I thought he might win, which would have made me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.
But Althea won? Seriously? Again, shows what I know. You crazy fashion people.
And finally, FINALLY, Project Runway remembers the rule that hideously ugly is always better than boring, and Qrystil gets sent home for her basic black dress. Logan lives to strip on camera for at least another episode. And, based on the previews for next week, I think we might finally get some unconventional materials to work with. It's a Festivus miracle!